Join MultiplyOpen a Free ShopSign InHelp
MultiplyLogo
SEARCH
ReviewReviewReviewReviewReviewJul 8, '06 4:41 PM
for everyone
Category:Movies
Genre: Drama
講種族 以為會略帶悶氣
其實係激動心靈的驚喜之作
我好鐘意唷~
crash 以洛杉磯為背景
用幾個故事人物將整套戲串連
再帶出一個極普遍的問題 種族歧視
因為有幾條人物線 所以複雜群戲多
感覺超難處理或拍得好睇

五粒星星的來歷
星一: 人物線清晰 會令你follow到
星二: 高效率 唔會當你白痴咁narrate
星三: 思考與批判 突然會自我檢討 警惕自己 發人遐想
星四: 教育性 <--好老土? 但係我近期好buy此戲種 movie=tool --->education/ propaganda
星五: 實至名歸 真係好睇過 brokeback mountain 等我仲以為呢套係最差添!

複雜群戲的人物線:
1)歧視黑人的白人警察
最終為救病重的父親向黑人醫生求助, 並在車禍中救了一個曾被自己侮辱過的黑人妻子(highlight of the movie 最有impact的一幕)
2)剛投身社會的白人警察
親眼目睹拍擋如何侮辱黑人妻子, 曾英勇協助黑人脫離險境
最終卻失手殺了一個黑人的白人警察
3)誓言尊重同色系的yo yo 黑人
發誓絕不搶黑人東西的黑人 最終還是搶黑人的車 掏槍指向黑人
4)有地位的白人法官
被黑人搶劫後 , 還要主動提出頒獎予黑人
5)疑神疑鬼的白人太太
一直認為所有黑人會爆格自己屋企 keep住要換鎖的白人太太
最終發現黑人女傭先至係好朋友
6)差d殺錯好人的波斯家族爸爸
是被歧視的對象 同時又歧視別人
更錯怪好人 差d將黑人鎖匠&女兒殺死
7) 被輾過的"中國人" (其實係korean 導演/編劇好似唔多識分亞洲人-.-")
亦似是被歧視的對象 同時將這種待遇轉嫁他人的人
竟然泛販賣人口 另一個極有potential 的課題:human trafficking !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

還有還有...
白人下屬 vs 黑人上司
黑人媽媽 vs 黑人仔仔
黑人仔仔 vs "mexico"女友同事
...........................................

幾amazing ?
一套戲 咁多關係 仲要寫得好睇先難嘛
佩服 佩服

最不安 留下伏筆 & 最愛的一句對白:
u think u know who u r , u hv no idea !


kwokkenneth wrote on Jul 10, '06
I've seen this several months ago.... I agree some of ur points though I can only give 3 star for this movie. 複雜群戲的人物線 I would prefer TRAFFIC, less "branches" but have same aim: the influence of drug everywhere. Here the scriptwriter wanna bring out a similar message:racism everywhere(esp. in LA), but his target is too high, I mean, the storyline is too dramatic in only 24 hrs! (Esp. the black wife of the TVdirector being rescue by the white guy who just sexual harrass her in less than 24 hrs! I really laugh at it when I saw that "rescue scene"... anyway, a bit 眼高手低
For that 錯綜複雜人物線, I like GOSFORD PARK, an good example of 眼高手高 by Robert Altman!

BTW, I agree that this film is better than BBM gei
Have u seen "Human Trafficking" by HBO? 有Mira Sorvino & Robert Carlo

Another movie I saw these days is Lord of War, Nicolas Cage, who is a BIG DEALER of weapons and sell them to countries all over the world, Gei Ok ga!
lo12 wrote on Jul 12, '06
我唔多鐘意Gosford Park, o係屋企訓住睇
human trafficking 就當然有睇,,,,超正
又係一套 movie = tool 的好例子
Mira Sorvino 同Robert Carlyle就無興趣la..但係戲中叫helena的女人,,,我仲以為係5x2個女主角...個樣勁似,我到宜家都分唔到,成日以為個"法國"女(上網check : 其實係italian)拍左咁多美國野tim

ps.
5x2女主角叫 Valeria Bruni Tedeschi, italy, 16 nov 1964
Raised bilingual by her French mother and her Italian father

human traffickking 的helena 叫 Isabelle Blais , canada , 1975


Add a Comment
How would you rate this movie? (optional)
0 out of 5 stars